Keeping Steven Kwan makes most sense for Cleveland Guardians

There are a select few players who have proven essential to the Cleveland Guardians organization. Jose Ramirez clearly gets headlining for obvious reasons, but when looking at the next group of names who deserves recognition, Steven Kwan is one of the next players who is mentioned. Kwan has proven himself to be incredibly valuable to the Guardians the last five seasons, and is someone the organization would be wise to keep around.

Now, there has not necessarily been an indication that the Guardians are looking to move Steven Kwan this offseason, with the front office stating they expect him to be on the roster next season. But as we all know, it’s incredibly difficult to take that at face value. The Guardians have been known to make statements like that previously, only to backtrack and trade said player not long after. So there is reason to be skeptical when the team says Kwan will be in Cleveland next season.

The impact of a possible MLB Lockout

At this point, just about everyone expects there to be a lockout. A work stoppage is not necessarily going to be kind to a team like the Cleveland Guardians. This is why there is some speculation about a possible trade of Steven Kwan.

The 29-year-old outfielder is entering his final arbitration eligible season. This works against the Guardians on two fronts. Not only is the projected $10.6 million salary a little outside Cleveland’s comfort zone, the possibility of Kwan leaving in free agency the following year barring an unforeseen contract extension isn’t helping either. The Guardians prefer to trade players before entering their final year of arbitration if possible. This usually allows for an extension of their competitive window, assuming things work out in their favor.

Another thing to consider is that it does not seem like other teams are willing to part ways with the cost-controlled players the Guardians prefer to acquire in situations like this. It is possible that this could prevent Cleveland from seriously considering trading Steven Kwan. Being able to operate in their normal manner is one thing. Without turning Kwan’s one year into multiple others, it may be more than enough for him to remain in Cleveland.

Steven Kwan is more valuable to the Cleveland Guardians than any other team

The way a particular organization values a player can be a funny thing. Just because a player is considered highly desirable by one does not mean that every other feels the same way. Is Steven Kwan elite defensively? Of course, it just is not valued as much. Teams would rather have an elite offensive player with passable defense rather than the opposite, and that’s where Kwan find himself.

The Guardians do not feature a heavy hitting lineup, with the above-mentioned Jose Ramirez being the key-driver of offensive production. Steven Kwan’s 110 OPS+ is slightly above average, giving them a solid offensive baseline to work from. It may not seem like much to other teams, but for Cleveland this matters a lot. It’s not exciting by any means, but it has proven to be impactful for the Guardians.

Unfortunately, as valuable as Kwan has proven to be in Cleveland, other organizations do not feel the same way. If they did, it’s likely Kwan would have been dealt already, either in 2025 or 2026, but he remains in a Guardians uniform. This puts Cleveland in a from ideal spot. Having a player they will likely not extend, but also not be able to trade away for a worthy return.

The best foot forward for the Guardians and Kwan is to stay the course. Steven Kwan may not be a franchise cornerstone like Ramirez, but if cornerstone-adjacent was a thing, it would apply here. Ideally, they extend him to a team-friendly deal, although that seems like wishful thinking. That’s what most thought about the extension they signed Ramirez to, so anything is indeed possible. That includes a new contract that would keep Steven Kwan in Cleveland.


Discover more from This Is Believeland

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share

Written by:

3,121 Posts

James Mastrucci covers the Cleveland Browns, Cavaliers, Guardians, and Monsters.
View All Posts
Follow Me :